Monday, April 18, 2011

Anthony Robles


This particular piece of journalism is important because only once does the author actually mention the fact that Anthony Robles is a wrestler who has one leg. If you were to read the entire article minus that sentence, you would have almost no idea that there was anything unique about Anthony at all. As we learned in our recent class session focusing on "disabilities", often any type of journalism focusing on people with some type of mental or physical disability either seeks to call to attention how miraculous it is that someone with a disability could have had such an accomplishment or it seeks to glorify the disability as the reason why this person has succeeded.

The author of this article remarks only a few times about anything physical at all when mentioning Robles, and aims to focus more on the tangible accomplishments this young man has achieved rather than note that the reason why these achievements are noteworthy are because he deviates from the "norm". Robles' story is uplifting, inspirational and motivational to people of all walks of life and is made to appear no more or less significant because Robles lacks one of his legs. If this article had chosen to focus on how Robles' achievements were more significant because he has only one leg, projected Robles as a wounded warrior and spoke more on the potential struggles Robles faced growing up with his disability, reading the article would elicit an entirely different reaction. If journalists chose to approach all matters of gender, race, culture, etc., with this type of neutrality, I believe that the media would be a much less opinionated and biased part of culture.

1 comment:

  1. I could not agree more about how well written this article was about Robles. I have been seeing more coverage on Robles, specifically on ESPN, and while they do emphasize the disability more than this article did, it is amazing that now it has shifted towards showing how an athlete worked to achieve greatness. However, even if media changes the framing of the issue, I wonder if the audience will shift their opinions. It is hard to change all agencies involved.

    I also found a story that I am sure you all remember about the autistic boy who scored six three-pointers for his basketball team. This story was completely opposite, in that even the child's mother focused on his disability. She is quoted as saying: "This is the first moment Jason has ever succeeded (and could be) proud of himself." You also see a quote from a teammate calling the boy, Jason, a "cool kid" as if he couldn't be cool on an everyday basis because he is autistic. http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2006/02/23/earlyshow/main1339324.shtml

    It just goes to show you that this "neutrality" you discuss in your post isn't just in the media but it is also ingrained so deeply in our own opinions.

    ReplyDelete